Johnston & Murphy Men's XC4 Tanner Plain Toe Oxford, Tan Full Grain, 10.5 M

The Johnston & Murphy Men's Amherst 2.0 Knit Plain Toe Dress Casual Shoe has garnered mixed reviews from customers, reflecting a blend of appreciation for its comfort and style, alongside significant criticisms regarding its practicality. On the positive side, many users find these shoes to be lightweight and stylish, making them an attractive option for casual or semi-formal wear. The comfort level has received commendation, suggesting that they are suitable for extended wear without causing discomfort. However, these positive attributes are overshadowed by design flaws that have left several customers dissatisfied. The principal issue highlighted is the shoe's sole design, which has been described as cup-shaped. This feature creates a 'popping' sound with every step, akin to suction cups, leading to an embarrassing experience in public settings. Additionally, the lack of traction on smooth surfaces has been a significant concern, with some users reporting near slips when walking on concrete. This combination of inadequate grip and noisy soles has led to frustration among those who hoped for a versatile and functional shoe. Overall, while the Johnston & Murphy Amherst 2.0 has the potential to be a stylish addition to one’s wardrobe, its current design shortcomings have prompted customers to recommend seeking alternatives within the brand's more traditional dress shoes. **